What is a Good Argument? (Part I)?

A good argument is like a strong tower that can keep people from being convinced by silly ideas.

Imagine you and your friend are trying to decide what game to play. You say "Let’s play tag!" but your friend says "No, let's play hide and seek!" That’s just a disagreement, it doesn’t mean either of you is right or wrong yet.

A good argument is when someone gives good reasons for why they think something is true. It’s like building a tower with blocks, each block is a reason that helps support the idea.

What Makes an Argument Strong?

Think about stacking blocks. If your friend says, "Hide and seek is better because it's more fun and you get to hide!", that’s a good argument. They gave a reason (it's more fun) and a supporting detail (you get to hide).

But if they just say, "No, I don’t want to play tag," without giving any reasons, it's like stacking one block, not very strong.

A good argument gives you enough blocks so that the tower stands tall and everyone can see why one game might be better than the other.

Take the quiz →

Examples

  1. A person says, 'I like chocolate,' but doesn't give a reason. That's not an argument.
  2. Someone argues that dogs are better than cats because they can fetch balls and protect the house.
  3. A student says their math teacher is unfair because all the tests were hard.

Ask a question

See also

Discussion

Recent activity