Is pluto a planet thats asking the wrong question?

Pluto used to be called a planet, but now it’s not, and that might be because we're asking the wrong question about what makes something a planet.

Imagine you’re playing with blocks in the sandbox. You make a tall tower with big blocks, and then you add little ones on top. At first, everyone thinks it's still a "big block tower." But one day, someone says, “Wait, those little blocks are just tiny planets now!” That’s kind of what happened with Pluto.

What is a planet?

A long time ago, people thought a planet was something that moved around the Sun and wasn’t too small. But when scientists looked closer, they found out Pluto is much smaller than Earth, it's more like a tiny ice ball in the far reaches of space.

So some scientists said, “Maybe we should change what a planet means.” That made Pluto not a planet anymore, but that doesn’t mean it’s not cool, it just means we might have been asking the wrong question all along. Pluto used to be called a planet, but now it’s not, and that might be because we're asking the wrong question about what makes something a planet.

Imagine you’re playing with blocks in the sandbox. You make a tall tower with big blocks, and then you add little ones on top. At first, everyone thinks it's still a "big block tower." But one day, someone says, “Wait, those little blocks are just tiny planets now!” That’s kind of what happened with Pluto.

Take the quiz →

Examples

  1. A kid asks, 'Why isn't Pluto a planet anymore?'
  2. A teacher explains that Pluto is now called a dwarf planet.
  3. A student draws a picture of the solar system without Pluto.

Ask a question

See also

Discussion

Recent activity