Ask A U.S. Citizen: Do Immigrants Commit More Crimes?

Imagine you're playing a game where everyone gets to pick how many cookies they eat, some people take one cookie, others take two, and some even take five! Now, if you only look at the kids who took five cookies, it might seem like those kids are the biggest troublemakers. But that’s not the whole story.

Immigrants are like new players joining your game. Some of them might end up taking more cookies, or maybe even breaking a cookie jar, but that doesn’t mean all immigrants are the ones causing the most chaos.

Why We Think Immigrants Commit More Crimes

Sometimes, when we hear about crimes in the news, it feels like all the people involved are new to town. That can make us think immigrants commit more crimes than everyone else, but that’s just because they’re more likely to be noticed when something happens.

It's like if you only watched the game when someone broke a cookie jar, of course, it would look like the biggest troublemakers were the ones who took five cookies!

The Real Picture

In reality, people from all backgrounds commit crimes. It’s just that sometimes, immigrants are more likely to be counted in crime stats than other groups, and that can make it seem like they’re doing more of the troublemaking.

So next time you hear someone say immigrants commit more crimes, remember: it's not always the whole story!

Take the quiz →

Examples

  1. A child asks, 'Do people who come to live in the U. S. commit more crimes than people born here?'
  2. A teacher explains that crime rates can vary by city and time period.
  3. An immigrant family hears about a local news story on crime.

Ask a question

See also

Discussion

Recent activity